Romance Tropes Bracket – August Matchup

by | Aug 13, 2026 | Romance Trope Bracket | 60 comments

Romance Tropes Tournament Bracket

Welcome to my Romance Trope Bracket Tournament. Once a month, I’m going to post a new matchup.

Comment with YOUR vote for which trope YOU prefer to read.

Then visit the tropes below to see my book recommendations for each trope.

Opposites Attract

 

The hero and heroine, who are opposites in temperament, personality, or other characteristics, end up falling for one another despite those differences.

Here are four of my favorite opposites-attract stories!

A Lady’s Guide to Marvels and Misadventure by Angela Bell

 

Beyond These War Torn Lands by Cynthia Roemer

Christmas at Whitefriars by Elizabeth Camden

The Convicts Courtship by KyLee Woodley

Anonymous Love & Secret Admirer

 

Involves characters who fall in love without knowing each other’s true identities, or a character who has romantic feelings for another person but keeps their identity hidden, often expressing their affection through anonymous gifts or letters.

Here are three of my favorite anonymous love / secret admirer stories.

Letters for Phoebe by Sally Britton

 

A Secret Correspondence by Kasey Stockton

 

An Agreeable Alliance by Kasey Stockton

Comment below with YOUR vote for favorite trope!

60 Comments

    • Carolyn Frazier

      My vote this month is opposites attract. It is not my overall favorite but preferred over the anonymous love/secret admirer.

      Reply
      • Crystal Caudill

        Hopefully we’ll hit your favorite in the coming months!

        Reply
  1. Karen Visnosky

    Anonymous Love / Secret Admirer

    Reply
    • Crystal Caudill

      I can’t wait to write the story that’s been simmering in my head for years, which is a Secret Admirer/Anonymous Love Christmas story. Now just to figure out when God wants that one actually written.

      Reply
  2. Teri DiVincenzo

    It’s completely impossible for contemporary books, but I just love marriage of convenience!

    Reply
    • Crystal Caudill

      Did you see that Sarah Monzon’s upcoming one is a contemporary marriage of convenience? I can’t wait to see how she pulls that off.

      Reply
      • Jennifer B.

        I enjoy variety, so opposites attract would be my choice.

        My hubby and I fall into this category. He came from a broken, neglected, abusive home and I came from a loving home like Leave it to Beaver. We met my last semester of college as coworkers. He was determined to give up looking for a Christian girl (because they “mercy dated” guys) and I had given up on guys in my state as they didn’t know how to “define the relationship” and just hung around. 😂

        Our marriage has not been perfect, but through patience, grace (modeled by our heavenly Father), commitment to Jesus and determination we’ve celebrated 23 years!

        Reply
        • Crystal Caudill

          What a beautiful testimony of that working, and congratulations on 23 years!

          Reply
  3. Kelsey Gietl

    What a fun idea! My vote for August is Opposites Attract.

    Reply
    • Crystal Caudill

      Thanks! I was hoping y’all would think it’s fun!

      Reply
  4. Jcp

    Marriage of convenience

    Reply
    • Lydia

      Nothing better then a good enemies to lovers. Im reading “A most perculiar circumstance” from Jen Turano right now. Big recommendation

      Reply
  5. Cindy

    Opposites Attract

    Reply
    • Crystal Caudill

      That is a fun trope to see how people balance each other out.

      Reply
  6. Kristi

    I prefer Opposites Attract over Secret Admirer

    Reply
    • Crystal Caudill

      That is a fun one to read. I like seeing how people can balance each other out.

      Reply
  7. Elinora

    My absolute favorite is Enemies-to-lovers, but for these two, Opposites Attract has to win!

    Reply
  8. Sarah Taylor

    Opposites attract is my vote

    Reply
  9. Vickie Waters

    Hard to choose one. Enemies to Lovers and Marriage of Convenience

    Reply
    • Jessie Bell

      Opposites Attract is my choice.

      Reply
    • Crystal Caudill

      Both of those are fun, and if they combined in the same book, extra fun!

      Reply
  10. Stacey Cochran

    Such a fun idea! I have recently started really to love fake relationship. Second chance is my favorite though!

    Reply
    • Crystal Caudill

      I’m glad you think it’s fun! It’s hit or miss for me on Fake Relationship, but I do love a good second chance!

      Reply
  11. Deborah Clark

    My favorite is opposites attract.

    Reply
  12. Dana McReynolds

    Opposites Attract

    Reply
  13. Susan Hunsinger

    Anonymous love/Secret admirer.

    Reply
    • Crystal Caudill

      Those are so fun. Sort of makes me think of “You’ve Got Mail” in some ways.

      Reply
  14. Voni Harris

    Definitely Opposites Attract. They do. Anonymous is too scary for a romance. Not for a suspense, lol

    Reply
  15. Kathleen Denly

    Opposites Attract

    Reply
  16. Alicia Haney

    Hi, I love the sound of Secret Admirer.

    Reply
    • Crystal Caudill

      I’ve enjoyed the few stories I’ve read with that.

      Reply
  17. Jan Stetson

    Opposites Attract 🙂

    Reply
  18. Laurie C.

    I like both but I’m leaning towards opposites attract. That said, I just read Sarah Monzon’s “Hearts in Circulation,” which isn’t about anonymous admirers, but it is about two people who fall in love as they write letters to each other. I’m not normally a rom-com person, but I’ve really enjoyed both books in this series.

    Reply
    • Crystal Caudill

      That series really has been a great one! I can’t wait to read the third book.

      Reply
  19. Lana Burton

    Opposites attract would be my normal response. The reason I chose this trope over secret admirer is because that can sound a little but creepy sometimes. I’ve had a stalker before and so I’m voting for opposites attract! ♥️♥️

    Reply
    • Crystal Caudill

      I can understand where it can be creepy! And I’m so sorry you had to deal with a stalker.

      Reply
  20. Aleah Cronk

    I think Opposites Attract is my favorite trope. It involves expanding your thinking to understand an entirely different kind of person.
    Some of the beauty in those stories is that they either find a new or deeper appreciation for those unique differences, or they find they have more in common than what appeared on the surface or at first glance. I’m reading a clean fiction audiobook right now that does both of these quite well; where she is a self-proclaimed science geek and he is worldly and cool “ladies man.”
    Betting on the Best Friend’s Brother, Betting on Love book 2, by Melanie Jacobson. (I also enjoyed book 1.)

    Reply
    • Crystal Caudill

      OH! Good to know. I’ll have to check that recommendation out. Thanks!

      Reply
      • Aleah Cronk

        Finished it! It was clever and very enjoyable!
        I just started bk 3, Betting on the Brainiac, and it appears to be a bit of opposites attract, as well. 🙂
        The series revolves around 4 post-college aged bff female roomates. One bets each of the others that she can find them true love in a certain time period, in exchange for something of theirs that she wants (reserved pkg spot, master suite w/private bath, deluxe bed). So far they are each quite creative & clever.

        Reply
  21. Diana Hardt

    Second chance

    Reply
    • Diana Hardt

      I went too far ahead. I meant opposites attract.

      Reply
  22. Connie Hendryx

    Anonymous Love/Secret Admirer…?

    Reply
    • Crystal Caudill

      Question marke because you’re not sure what it is, or if you’re not sure that’s what you would vote for?

      Reply
  23. Sabrina

    I enjoy both, but I’ll put my vote to Anonymous Love & Secret Admirer. 🙂

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest