Ask the Author about Written in Secret

by Crystal Caudill | Mar 25, 2025 | Author Interviews

Written in Secret has been out in the world for an entire week and I cannot thank you enough for the wonderful outpouring of support, encouragement, and reviews! If you’ve already read Written in Secret, I’ve created a Facebook Discussion group where you can talk all about it with others who have read it too! I hope to see you there!

While you’ve met a few of the characters–Lydia, Abraham, and Billy Poe (on Reading is My Superpower), I thought it might be fun to share an interview with myself about the book. 🙂 There are the usual giveaways at the end of the post, but you’ll also have the chance to ask me YOUR questions. It might take me a few days to get back to them, but I’ll be responding to each one. Who knows, maybe I’ll post a few on social media too! 

Can you tell us a little bit about your new novel, Written in Secret?

Lydia Pelton is a dime novelist who writes romances under her own name but secretly writes crime novels under the pseudonym E.A. Dupin. However, someone is murdering the exonerated criminals whose cases she based her novels on. The police suspect Dupin, but how can a man who doesn’t exist commit murder? Some poor decisions have left her at odds with Officer Abraham Hall, but she’ll never prove Dupin’s innocence without him or find the vigilante who’s determined to prove his love for her through murder.

 What sparked the idea for Written in Secret?

I’ve always enjoyed movies, television episodes, and novels where the concept of a book is brought to life. As a historical romantic suspense author, I was excited to toy with the idea of someone bringing a mystery author’s books to life for nefarious purposes. I’m also a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles fan, and the vigilante character Casey Jones inspired the idea of including a villain with noble intentions executed in a very vile way.

 What themes present themselves throughout the novel? Which ones speak most to readers today?

When this story began percolating in my imagination, the country wrestled with “What is justice?” and “How should injustice be handled when we feel our justice system has failed us?” There was lots of rioting, talk of vigilante justice, and discourse on how things should be handled within the constraints of the law. I’m not sure society ever agreed on what those answers should be. I never aimed to answer those questions for my readers but to spark discussion and thought on our response to injustice as Christ-following believers.

Why did you choose 1880 Cincinnati as your setting?

During this period, Cincinnati had a reputation for corruption. Criminals often walked away with lesser sentences or no conviction if they had the right political connections or financial ability to grease palms. Juries, judges, and officers could be and were bought. Elections were known to be rigged, and the citizens felt helpless to change anything. On top of that, the restructuring of police management through a board of police commissioners failed in early 1880. After that, the running of the police department fell under the mayor’s responsibilities. The mayor appointed or fired officers. Sometimes, they were fired for something as simple as having a differing political view. It was a volatile time that actually led to a major riot in 1884 that killed 58 and injured far more. It was the perfect storm for the setting of my novel.

 What will fans of romance love about your story and characters?

I hope readers will love the banter between Lydia and Abraham and how they help each other grow as Christians and individuals. I also hope readers will spy all my little pokes of fun at romance novels and how I purposely twist expectations. 

What was the most fascinating thing you found during your research that shaped your story?

I’ll try to keep this brief because I could talk about this for hours. Bottom line: Dime novels revolutionized reading and were met with significant opposition. Before the invention of dime novels, books cost $1 to $3 each, putting them firmly out of reach for the average worker who only made $5 to $8 a week. Dime novels were 100-page paper leaflets that sold for between a nickel and twenty-five cents and made reading material available to the common man, woman, and child. However, the middle and upper classes generally opposed their existence. Many viewed dime novels as soul-corrupting and leading to an increase in crime from the lower class. Many lobbied to ban them, even though members of all classes read them. This societal dissonance shaped the direction of my story, my heroine’s reasoning for hiding behind a pseudonym, and Cincinnati’s response to discovering my heroine not only wrote romance novels but also mystery novels that dove into the underbelly of the criminal world.

 If readers have read Counterfeit Love, they have already met Lydia and Abraham as side characters. What new things will readers learn and love about them in this new story?

Written in Secret takes place four years before Counterfeit Love and tells the romance story of Theresa’s best friend. While Lydia was firmly rooted in Christ by Counterfeit Love, Written in Secret shows Lydia’s growth in her faith walk. Like many Christians, Lydia feels her relationship with Jesus is good enough. However, when a vigilante uses her stories to commit murder, she’s confronted with the lies she’s used to get published, obtain research, and hide her identity from even her family. Readers will get a front-row seat to her growth, wild imagination, and humor.

Abraham is the sensibility to her madness, although Lydia is a puzzle to him. He first met her when he arrested her and Theresa for attempting to “rescue” a three-legged goat from the circus. She’s a temptation to figure out, but he wants no future with a criminal dime novelist who can’t take responsibility for her decisions. Still, their banter and the need to protect her from the vigilante her books created bring him into constant contact with her. The road to becoming a detective is difficult, but with Lydia in the way, it’s nearly impossible.

 The villain is unique. Can you tell us a little about him?

Lydia’s crime novels featured a detective hero named Billy Poe. In her stories, Billy Poe investigated crimes that exactly matched the cases that inspired the story. However, in each book, before they could be arrested, the criminals met similar fates to the crimes for which they’d escaped punishment. In her fictional world, Billy Poe is the hero, but someone in the real world has taken on Billy Poe’s identity and is murdering the criminals from the original cases exactly how they die in the books Lydia wrote. He leaves quotes from the book on the bodies and claims the deed. However, no one knows who he is. At first, people believe him to be the author, E.A. Dupin, but when it’s discovered Dupin is Lydia’s pseudonym, the police (and hopefully the reader) are left with no idea who the true villain is.

Written in Secret is the first book in the The Art of Love and Danger series. Please tell us about the series.

The series contains three books that follow four friends who each have a talent or career related to one of the arts. Theresa paints and engraves, Lydia is a dime novelist, Nora secretly sings and writes songs, and Flossie creates and paints pottery. Each woman’s art plays a significant role in the plots and how they face the problems around them. And, of course, love and danger will pursue them through each page. Only three of the four friends have books in this series, but you can read Counterfeit Love for Theresa’s story. While each book can be read as a stand-alone, the series will best be enjoyed by reading them in order.

What do you hope readers take away from reading Written in Secret?

My biggest hope is that they’ll walk away having read a story that excited and entertained them. On the “deeper” side of things, I hope readers will walk away knowing that God is still just and able even when there is injustice in the world. Sometimes, God will use injustice to change a person’s heart toward Him, and sometimes, we never get a reason or explanation. But we can act justly, love mercy, and walk humbly with God.

What is a fun fact about this book that readers might not know?

The four friends who call themselves “the Guardians” are inspired by my core critique group and friends, “the Mayhemmers.” We came together as mostly unpublished writers and have now all walked through the published author door supporting each other in our careers, personal lives, and spiritual walks. And that is what each of “the Guardians” does. Each character has qualities loosely based on each of these ladies. I tend to behave like Theresa, Liz Bradford like Lydia, Angela Carlisle like Nora, and Voni Harris and Flossie share some of the same characteristics. It’s been fun tucking in qualities of my best friends into a fictional world. 

What kind of research did you do for this book?

There was an eclectic range of topics I needed to study. I spent the most time researching dime novels, from their history to the publication culture surrounding getting published, then to the societal reaction to dime novels. Of course, I read a few to gain an understanding of their style and content. I also did a massive amount of research on the history of the Cincinnati police department. It was actually a pretty complicated history where dates were incredibly important to make sure I knew who was over the department (a board or the mayor), what resources they had or didn’t have available (telephones before police wagons), how they were structured, where the stations were, and so much more. I adored every minute of it. A special treat was visiting the Greater Cincinnati Police Museum and getting a personal tour from a former chief of police and historian for the museum.

Written in Secret by Crystal Caudill

In the heart of nineteenth-century Cincinnati one woman holds the power to rewrite history.

What happens when fiction becomes reality? In the corruption-infested Queen City, danger lurks in every shadow, but Lydia Pelton refuses to stay silent. She writes under a pseudonym, E. A. Dupin, crafting crime novels to exact justice and right the wrongs she sees in society. When a serial killer decides to be the sword to her pen, Lydia is confronted with the consequences of her words. Four men are dead, and the city blames her.

With murders on the rise, Officer Abraham Hall’s only lead is Lydia’s fiction, and he is thrust into an investigation with the “Killer Queen of Romance.” Despite his misgivings about the woman, he realizes that even with his reputation for catching elusive criminals, he needs her help. But his unexpected attraction to Lydia proves as difficult to manage as the woman herself.

As the mystery unfolds, Abraham and Lydia race to rewrite the ending, not only for Cincinnati’s citizens, but for their own hearts too.

Purchase Links:  Amazon  |  Apple Books  |  Baker Book House  |  Barnes & Noble |  Books-A-Million  | Christianbook  |  IndieBound  | Kobo

Month-Long Blog Giveaway

Help me celebrate the release of Written in Secret and get the word out about the new series. From March 4 to April 1, this giveaway will be open to those legally allowed to enter both domestically and internationally. International winners will be given a prize of equal value as shipping costs are prohibitive. See my giveaway policies for more details.

Prize: homemade book cozy, fuzzy socks, journal, reader mug mat, bookmarks, stickers, tea, and chapstick.

a Rafflecopter giveaway

Month-Long Giveaway #2

Already have the book?? This giveaway is for you. Somewhere in the first fifty pages of Written in Secret is the answer to “What attacked Lydia and Abraham inside the circus tent?” Fill out the below Google Form to be entered for your chance to win a $25 gift card to Amazon or Baker Book House. The giveaway runs until April 11, 2024. The winner will be selected the week of April 12 and notified by email.

Enter Here

Readers, comment with:

What questions do YOU have for me?